How to Legally Deny a Rental Application

Image: Freepix

Renting out property is a significant responsibility, and landlords must carefully screen applicants to ensure they find reliable tenants. However, denying a rental application must always be done within the legal framework to avoid potential discrimination claims and legal repercussions. Below are the key steps to legally deny a rental application.

1. Establish Clear Rental Criteria

Before reviewing applications, landlords should establish and document clear rental criteria, including:

• Minimum credit score requirement

• Income-to-rent ratio

• Rental history and references

• Criminal background checks (as permitted by law)

• Pet policies

Ensuring these criteria are written and applied consistently helps protect landlords from discrimination claims.

2. Comply with Fair Housing Laws

The Fair Housing Act (FHA) prohibits discrimination based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, or disability. Additionally, some states and local jurisdictions have expanded protections that landlords must follow. Denials should be based solely on legitimate business criteria rather than any protected class.

3. Conduct a Background Check Consistently

When screening applicants, apply the same standards to all applicants. A background check may include:

• Credit history

• Eviction records

• Criminal history (subject to legal restrictions)

• Employment and income verification

4. Provide a Legitimate Reason for Denial

If an application is denied, the reason should be clear and legally valid. Common legitimate reasons for denial include:

• Insufficient income (failure to meet income-to-rent ratio)

• Poor credit history (low credit score, history of missed payments)

• Negative rental history (evictions, complaints, or unpaid rent)

• False information on the application

• Criminal background issues (depending on severity and relevancy to tenancy)

• Exceeding occupancy limits

5. Provide a Written Denial Letter (If Required)

While not always legally required, providing a written denial letter is best practice and, in some cases, mandatory under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). If the denial is based on credit history, landlords must:

• Inform the applicant in writing

• Provide the name and contact information of the credit reporting agency used

• State that the applicant has the right to request a free copy of their report and dispute inaccuracies

6. Avoid Discriminatory or Retaliatory Actions

A denial should never be based on retaliation or discrimination. Avoid:

• Rejecting applicants due to complaints against previous landlords

• Favoring one applicant over another based on personal biases

• Denying reasonable accommodation requests for disabled applicants

7. Keep Records of All Applications and Denials

Maintaining thorough records of applications, background checks, and reasons for denial can help protect landlords if an applicant claims discrimination. Keep these records for at least one to two years.

Conclusion

Denying a rental application is a landlord's right, but it must be done lawfully and ethically. By following fair housing laws, applying consistent screening criteria, and maintaining proper documentation, landlords can protect their properties while minimizing legal risks.

For more information on properties located in Baltimore, MD, click here.